Last year's class recommended that I give an example of a proposal review. Here is a review that I did a couple of years ago. The name has been omitted to protect the innocent etc.
I hope this will be of some help even though the original paper is not available. At the least it will provide a sense of the level of detail needed for a reasonable review.
Comments on title by author
by L. A. Becker
You will find penciled check marks next to citations in your text and in front of each work cited in your Reference section. You can ignore them, they are my way of matching text citations with works cited in the References.
"APA x.xx" refers to section x.xx of the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association, Fourth Edition.